1833 $5 BD-1, Large Date MS(PCGS#519952)

Summer 2026 Global Showcase Auction U.S. Coins

Auctioneer

Stack's Bowers

Lot Number

2321

Grade

AU58

Price

67,100

Lot Description

BD Die State a/c. This 1833 half eagle presents nicely for an NGC AU-58 of this extremely challenging pre-1834 U.S. Mint gold issue; its offering in this sale represents another important bidding opportunity for astute gold specialists. Both sides are overall boldly defined with trivial softness of detail confined to a few isolated elements of the design. Bright olive-gold color is seen on both sides. Ample frosty luster remains, the fields revealing decided semi-reflectivity. Wispy handling marks are easily overlooked.<p>Until 1829, all gold coins were struck using a press that employed an open collar. In that year, the Philadelphia Mint introduced a press with a close collar that could also impart edge reeding. This innovation allowed coins to be struck at a consistent and slightly smaller diameter. At the same time, more half eagles were produced than in previous years, with 193,630 half eagles of all varieties minted in 1833. There are two prominent varieties: the Large Date, as here, and the Small Date, both of approximately equal rarity. All of the Large Date pieces were struck from a single die pair, BD-1, with the numerals in the date widely spaced. All Capped Head Left half eagles are well known rarities. Virtually the entire mintage of 1833 half eagles went overseas and was melted. The coins were valued as bullion only. The face value was irrelevant. On June 28, 1834, Congress took action by reducing the fineness as well as the weight of all gold coins. The new coins circulated widely. Meanwhile the few remaining "old tenor" (as they were called) half eagles were withdrawn gradually from circulation by the Mint for recoining into "new tenor" Classic Head half eagles. The inclusion of any Capped Head Left half eagle in a collection is a mark of achievement. The present coin is an above average example of a very scarce type, just right for the advanced collector.